Recommendation How To Write A Good Referee Report
Just begin with something like this.
How to write a good referee report. In my opinion the best referee reports have a few essential elements. Let the editors know if you need any additional information from the authors to help you write a balanced and well-substantiated report. Just saying We have done what the referees asked is insufficient.
Be intimidated by big names or famous research groups. A character reference letter provides employers with a third-party account of a candidates personal attributes and character traits. B the authors strategy for establishing the thesis and.
Include specific examples of how theyve displayed relevant qualities and character traits. Quite a lot of referees simply paraphrase the abstract of the papers they are reviewing. Posted on April 23 2013 by holly.
Kates Grade Point Average in her first year is very good 500 and she has achieved Distinction 75 to 85 grades along with the majority of Credits 65 to 74 that she obtained in her first semester with us. Weve already published pieces on how to write a scientific. A the thesis of the paper.
More specifically must-address statements require a scientifically convincing argument for why these problems currently render the paper unpub-lishable. In my case I actually dont mind providing references for two reasons. How to Write an Effective Referee Report and Improve the Scientific Review Process by Jonathan B.
Feedback to the authors that you understood the paper. Or theyll provide references but hate the time-suck for having to write it out. To educate the editor to convince the editor and other referees that youve actually read the paper no joke 2.